Homemade Lemon Verbena Limoncello Recipe

There are some flavors that just transport you, and for me, lemon is one of them. I’ll never forget the first time I had real, honest-to-goodness Limoncello. We were on a little anniversary trip, tucked away in a tiny Italian restaurant that smelled like garlic and old-world charm. After a wonderful meal, the owner brought out two tiny, frosted glasses filled with a glowing, sunshine-yellow liquid.

One sip and I was completely smitten. It was intensely lemon, but smooth and sweet, and it felt like sunshine sliding down my throat. I knew right then and there I had to learn how to make it myself. Back home, I started experimenting with the classic recipe, but I felt like it was missing something. It was lovely, but I wanted a signature touch, something that would make people say, “Wow, what is that?”

The answer was growing right in my own herb garden. Lemon verbena, with its incredible bright, floral-lemon fragrance, was the perfect partner. It doesn’t overpower the classic lemon zest, it just dances alongside it, adding a layer of fresh, green complexity. It turned a simple, beautiful liqueur into something truly special. This Lemon Verbena Limoncello is my little piece of the Amalfi Coast, with a Southern garden twist.

Skip to My Special Recipe!

Why This Limoncello Recipe Works

Limoncello is a classic Italian liqueur that hails from the sun-drenched shores of Southern Italy, most famously the Amalfi Coast. Traditionally, it’s served ice-cold after a meal as a “digestivo” to help settle the stomach and end the evening on a sweet, bright note. Its popularity comes from its simplicity. At its core, it is just lemon zest, alcohol, sugar, and water. When made well, it captures the pure, unadulterated essence of fresh lemons.

The magic is in the method. High-proof alcohol is used to extract the fragrant essential oils from the lemon zest, which is where all that incredible flavor lives. The infused alcohol is then sweetened with a simple syrup to create a balanced, sippable liqueur. It’s a recipe that has stood the test of time because it’s both simple to make and incredibly rewarding.

So, why mess with a classic? Well, I believe in enhancing, not overpowering. My secret ingredient, fresh lemon verbena, is what makes this Limoncello recipe a true standout. Lemon verbena has a unique aroma that is more intensely lemony than a lemon itself, but with added floral and herbaceous notes. It brings a sophisticated complexity and a whisper of green freshness to the final product.

Instead of just a single note of bright lemon, you get a beautiful melody of citrus and herbs. It elevates the drink from a simple liqueur to a craft creation. This little twist creates a Limoncello that is smoother, more aromatic, and wonderfully refreshing, making every sip an experience to savor.

Ingredients for Limoncello

The beauty of this recipe is its short and sweet ingredient list. But because there are so few components, the quality of each one really shines through. Don’t be tempted to cut corners here, as using the best ingredients you can find will make all the difference in your final homemade Limoncello.

• 10 large organic lemons
• 1 bunch fresh lemon verbena (approximately 1 cup of leaves)
• 1 (750 ml) bottle of 100-proof vodka or 151-proof grain alcohol
• 3 ½ cups filtered water
• 2 ½ cups granulated sugar

Let’s talk a little more about these key players. For the lemons, it is absolutely essential to use organic and unwaxed ones. Since we are using only the zest, you want to avoid steeping pesticides and wax into your beautiful liqueur. Look for lemons with thick, bright, oily skin, as they will have the most fragrant zest. Eureka or Lisbon lemons work perfectly.

The star of my version is the fresh lemon verbena. This fragrant herb is the twist that makes this Limoncello recipe so special. If you have it in your garden, fantastic! If not, you can often find it at farmers’ markets or well-stocked grocery stores in the fresh herb section. You want vibrant green leaves that release a powerful lemon scent when you gently rub them.

When it comes to the alcohol, a higher proof is better. A 100-proof vodka is a great, accessible choice. If you can find it, a 151-proof grain alcohol (like Everclear, though its availability varies by state) is even more efficient at extracting the lemon oils. A standard 80-proof vodka will work in a pinch, but the infusion may take longer and the lemon flavor might be a little less punchy.

Finally, for the simple syrup, using filtered water ensures a clean taste that won’t interfere with the lemon and herb flavors. Plain granulated sugar is all you need to provide the perfect balance of sweetness.

Step-by-Step Instructions For Making Limoncello

Making Limoncello is more of a patient waiting game than a complex cooking project. The process is simple and straightforward, so just follow along and you’ll be rewarded with a spectacular homemade liqueur. Grab your jars and let’s get started.

Step 1: Wash and Prep Your Citrus and Herbs

Start by giving your lemons and the bunch of lemon verbena a very thorough wash under cool water. Since the peels and leaves are the main event, you want them sparkling clean. Pat everything completely dry with a clean kitchen towel. Any excess water can dilute the alcohol and affect the infusion process.

Step 2: Peel the Lemons

Using a sharp vegetable peeler, carefully remove the yellow zest from all ten lemons. The key here is to get only the yellow part, avoiding the bitter white pith underneath. Work in long, wide strips if you can, as they are easier to handle and strain out later. A good quality Y-peeler is your best friend for this task.

Step 3: Combine Ingredients for Infusion

Find a large glass jar, at least a half-gallon in size, with a tight-fitting lid. Place all the beautiful lemon zest strips and the fresh lemon verbena leaves into the bottom of the jar.

Step 4: Add the Alcohol

Pour the entire 750 ml bottle of high-proof vodka or grain alcohol over the lemon zest and verbena in the jar. Make sure everything is completely submerged in the liquid. This is crucial for proper flavor extraction.

Step 5: Infuse the Mixture

Seal the jar tightly and give it a gentle swirl. Now comes the hard part: waiting. Store the jar in a cool, dark place, like a pantry or a cupboard, for at least 10 days. I find the sweet spot is around three to four weeks. Give the jar a gentle shake every few days to help the infusion along. You’ll see the alcohol start to take on a brilliant yellow color.

Step 6: Prepare the Simple Syrup

Once the infusion period is over, it’s time to make the simple syrup. In a medium saucepan, combine the 3 ½ cups of filtered water and 2 ½ cups of granulated sugar over medium heat.

Step 7: Dissolve the Sugar

Stir the mixture continuously until you see that all the sugar crystals have completely dissolved into the water. It’s important not to let the mixture come to a boil. You’re just looking to create a clear, sweet syrup.

Step 8: Cool the Syrup

Once the sugar is dissolved, remove the saucepan from the heat and set it aside. You must let the simple syrup cool completely to room temperature. Adding hot syrup to the cold alcohol can make the final Limoncello cloudy.

Step 9: Strain the Infused Alcohol

Place a fine-mesh sieve lined with a piece of cheesecloth over a large, clean bowl. Carefully pour the infused alcohol mixture through the sieve to remove all the lemon zest and verbena leaves. Don’t press on the solids, as this can release bitterness. Just let it drain naturally.

Step 10: Combine Syrup and Alcohol

Slowly pour the cooled simple syrup into the strained, infused alcohol. Stir gently with a whisk or spoon until the two liquids are fully combined. Your Limoncello is now officially made!

Step 11: Bottle the Limoncello

Using a funnel, carefully transfer the finished Limoncello into clean, sealable glass bottles. Swing-top bottles are a great choice both for storing and for gifting.

Step 12: Mellow the Flavors

For the absolute best flavor, let the bottled Limoncello rest for another week or two at room temperature or in the fridge. This mellowing period allows the flavors to meld together beautifully, resulting in a smoother, more harmonious taste.

Step 13: Chill and Serve

Finally, store your precious Limoncello in the freezer for at least four hours, or preferably overnight, before serving. It should be syrupy, icy-cold, and absolutely delicious.

How To Serve Limoncello

Serving this homemade Lemon Verbena Limoncello is a delightful ritual in itself. The classic, and arguably best, way to enjoy it is to serve it ice-cold, straight from the freezer. The high alcohol and sugar content keep it from freezing solid, giving it a slightly thick, syrupy consistency that is simply divine. It’s traditionally served as a digestif after dinner, a perfect sweet note to end a heavy meal.

I recommend keeping a few small cordial or shot glasses in the freezer right alongside the bottle. Pouring the chilled liqueur into a frosted glass makes the experience feel extra special and keeps it cold for longer as you sip and savor. A little goes a long way, so small, 1-ounce pours are perfect.

While drinking it straight is a time-honored tradition, this Limoncello is wonderfully versatile and can be used in a variety of other ways to add a splash of sunshine to drinks and desserts. Here are a few of my favorite ways to serve it:

• Limoncello Spritz: This is my go-to summer porch sipper. Fill a wine glass with ice, add one part Limoncello, three parts Prosecco or other sparkling wine, and a splash of club soda. Garnish with a lemon wheel and a fresh mint sprig. It’s incredibly refreshing.
• Dessert Drizzle: Gently pour a little Limoncello over a scoop of good quality vanilla bean ice cream or a slice of angel food cake. The liqueur soaks in and adds a burst of sophisticated lemon flavor that is just heavenly.
• In a Lemon Drop Martini: Give this classic cocktail an upgrade. Use this homemade Limoncello in place of some of the simple syrup or triple sec for a more complex and aromatic lemon flavor.
• Fruit Salad Enhancer: Add a tablespoon or two to a fresh berry salad. The Limoncello brightens the flavor of the fruit and adds a lovely, sweet tang that ties everything together.

No matter how you choose to serve it, this Limoncello is all about celebrating bright, fresh flavors. It’s perfect for sharing with friends after a dinner party or for enjoying as a quiet, personal treat at the end of a long day.

How To Store & Reuse Limoncello Leftovers

Properly storing your homemade Limoncello is key to preserving its vibrant flavor and beautiful color. The absolute best place for your finished product is in the freezer. Thanks to the alcohol and sugar content, it won’t freeze solid, but it will become wonderfully thick, syrupy, and perfectly chilled for serving. Keeping it in the freezer also helps preserve its freshness for the longest possible time.

Sealed tightly in glass bottles, your Limoncello will last for at least a year in the freezer, though I find its flavor is at its absolute peak within the first six months. You can also store it in the refrigerator, where it will last for several months, or even in a cool, dark cabinet. However, it will not be properly chilled for serving straight from the cabinet, and I find the freezer truly is the superior storage spot for both longevity and enjoyment.

Now, let’s talk about “leftovers.” Once you strain your infused alcohol, you’re left with a pile of alcohol-soaked lemon peels and verbena leaves. It seems like such a shame to just throw them away, and you don’t have to! Here are a couple of clever ideas to give them a second life:

• Make Candied Lemon Peels: You can take the strained lemon peels and simmer them in a simple syrup (equal parts sugar and water) until they are tender and translucent. Then, let them dry on a wire rack and toss them in granulated sugar. They make a fantastic garnish for cocktails, a topping for cakes, or a sweet treat all on their own.
• Create a Lemon Sugar Scrub: Dry the lemon peels completely in a low oven or a dehydrator. Once they are crisp, pulse them in a food processor with coarse sugar and a little coconut oil. This creates a fragrant and exfoliating body scrub that makes a wonderful homemade gift.
• Infuse a Simple Syrup: Place the leftover peels in a jar and cover them with a freshly made, warm simple syrup. Let it infuse for a day or two in the refrigerator, then strain. You’ll have a lightly alcoholic, intensely lemon-flavored syrup perfect for cocktails or sweetening iced tea.

By thinking creatively, you can make sure every bit of those beautiful organic lemons gets put to good use, which is something this Southern gal always appreciates. No waste and more deliciousness is always a win-win.

Substitutions & Variations For Limoncello

One of the best things about a simple, foundational recipe like this is how easily it can be adapted. Once you’ve mastered this Lemon Verbena Limoncello, you can start playing around with different flavors to create your own signature liqueurs. The basic process of infusing a high-proof spirit remains the same, so feel free to get creative.

If you don’t have lemon verbena on hand or want to try something different, there are plenty of other herbs that pair beautifully with lemon. Fresh mint can create a bright, mojito-esque liqueur, while basil adds a lovely, sweet, and slightly peppery note. A sprig of rosemary would add a wonderful piney, savory complexity that is surprisingly delicious. Just swap out the lemon verbena for your herb of choice and follow the recipe as written.

Don’t feel limited to just lemons, either. This technique works wonderfully with other citrus fruits. Here are a few variations you might want to try:

• Arancello (Orange): Use the zest from organic oranges, particularly flavorful varieties like Valencia or blood oranges, for a sweeter, warmer-tasting liqueur. A cinnamon stick or a few cloves added to the infusion would be a wonderful winter variation.
• Pompelmocello (Grapefruit): The zest of pink or red grapefruits creates a beautiful coral-colored liqueur with a pleasant, bittersweet flavor profile that is very sophisticated.
• Limecello (Lime): Using lime zest results in a zesty, tart liqueur that is perfect for adding a serious punch to margaritas or gin-based cocktails.
• Creamy Limoncello (Crema di Limoncello): For a decadent, dessert-like version, you can make a “crema.” After making the simple syrup, let it cool, and then whisk in whole milk or heavy cream before combining it with the strained alcohol. This version must be stored in the refrigerator and consumed within a few weeks.

You can also adjust the sweetness to your personal preference. If you prefer a tart, less sweet Limoncello, you can reduce the amount of sugar in the simple syrup to 2 cups. For a sweeter, more dessert-like liqueur, you can increase it to 3 cups. It’s your creation, so make it just the way you like it!

5 FAQs About Limoncello

Here are some straightforward answers to the most common questions I receive about this Limoncello recipe.

Why is my homemade Limoncello cloudy?

A cloudy Limoncello is not a sign of failure, in fact, many people prefer it! This cloudiness is known as the “ouzo effect” or louching. It happens when the essential oils that you’ve so carefully extracted from the lemon peels, which are soluble in high-proof alcohol, suddenly come out of solution when the water-based simple syrup is added. This creates a spontaneous emulsion, turning the clear liquid into a milky, opaque yellow.

Whether your Limoncello becomes cloudy depends on several factors, including the oil content of your lemons, the proof of your alcohol, and the temperature of your simple syrup when you mix it. A higher concentration of lemon oils is more likely to create this effect. Also, adding a warm or even room-temperature simple syrup to the cold infused alcohol can shock the mixture and cause cloudiness. For a clearer result, ensure your simple syrup is thoroughly chilled before you combine it with the strained alcohol.

What is the best alcohol to use for making Limoncello?

The best alcohol for making Limoncello is a high-proof, neutral spirit. The higher the alcohol content, the more efficiently it will extract the flavorful oils from the lemon zest. The gold standard for many traditional recipes is a 190-proof (95% ABV) pure grain alcohol, like Everclear. However, this is not available for purchase in all states and can be quite potent.

A more accessible and excellent alternative is a 100-proof (50% ABV) vodka. It’s strong enough to do a fantastic job of extraction while being a bit smoother and less harsh than pure grain spirits. Look for a clean, neutral vodka without a lot of added flavors. I would avoid using standard 80-proof (40% ABV) vodka if you can. While it will work, the lower alcohol content is less effective at extracting the oils, meaning you’ll need a longer infusion time and the final lemon flavor may be less intense and more “watered down.”

How long does homemade Limoncello last?

Thanks to its high alcohol and sugar content, homemade Limoncello is a very stable liqueur with a long shelf life. When stored properly in a tightly sealed bottle, it will last for a very long time without spoiling. For the best quality and flavor, I recommend storing it in the freezer. This keeps it perfectly chilled and ready to serve, and it will easily last for at least a year, and likely up to two years, without any significant loss of flavor or color.

You can also store it in the refrigerator, where it will be good for many months. If you store it at room temperature in a cool, dark cabinet, it will still be safe to drink for a year or more, but you may notice its vibrant yellow color fading over time due to light exposure. However, for that classic, syrupy-cold serving experience, the freezer is definitely the way to go.

Can I make Limoncello with less sugar?

Absolutely. The amount of sugar in a Limoncello recipe is very much a matter of personal taste. My recipe provides a nice balance that is sweet but not cloying, which is how I prefer it. However, you can easily adjust the simple syrup to suit your palate. If you prefer a more tart, spirit-forward liqueur, you can reduce the sugar to 2 cups while keeping the water amount the same. This will result in a drier, more potent-tasting Limoncello.

Conversely, if you have a real sweet tooth and want your Limoncello to be more of a dessert-like indulgence, you can increase the sugar to 3 cups. Just remember that sugar does more than just sweeten the drink. It also contributes to the liqueur’s body and smooth, syrupy texture, especially when chilled. Experimenting with a small batch is a great way to find your perfect sweetness level.

Why does my Limoncello taste bitter?

A bitter taste in Limoncello almost always comes from one culprit: the pith. The pith is the white, spongy layer between the yellow zest and the actual lemon fruit. While the zest is packed with fragrant, delicious oils, the pith is full of bitter compounds. It is absolutely crucial to avoid getting any of the pith into your infusion. When you are peeling your lemons, use a light touch and try to take off only the very top yellow layer.

Another, less common, cause of bitterness can be over-infusion, though this is rare with lemon zest. If you were to leave the peels in the alcohol for many, many months, some bitterness could potentially leach out. Finally, squeezing or pressing the peels when you are straining the alcohol can also release some of those bitter compounds. Let the liquid drain naturally through the sieve for the cleanest, purest flavor.

Try These Recipes Next

If you loved the bright, zesty flavor of this Limoncello, I know you’ll enjoy these other lemon-forward recipes from the blog.

• The Best Lemon Drop Martini: A perfectly balanced, sweet and tart cocktail that’s a classic for a reason.
• Oh So Lemon Bars: The ultimate lemon bars with a buttery shortbread crust and a thick, tangy lemon filling.
• Lemon Coconut Pudding Cakes: Magical little cakes that separate into a light sponge on top and a creamy lemon pudding on the bottom as they bake.

Give them a try and bring a little more sunshine into your kitchen!